Oh England My Lionheart

(17 comments)

Oh England My Lionheart
Tour of Life

This essay was brought to you by 17 backers on Patreon. Many thanks to the lovely people who give me some money to read my stuff every month. El's not the only person who needs a bit of help here. If you’d like to help a low-income queer writer trying to get herself on the ground, please consider backing me. I’m planning Q&A livestreams and essays which will be available exclusively on Patreon. In fact I’m doing a Q&A livestream tomorrow at 2 PM EST, so if you back me now you can tune in and ask me some questions. I’m in a difficult place financially, so any support would mean the world to me. You can find my Patreon here.

It's difficult to imagine Kate Bush heralding from any place except England. It’s certainly easy to understand why she’s popular in countries outside the U.K., but Bush is a uniquely English phenomenon. She came from pastoral England and often sings about British culture. Her work, especially on Lionheart, is full of allusions to English and Irish folklore, and she’s predominantly influenced by British music (glam rock was also a chiefly UK-locked phenomenon). Unlike most British rock singers, Bush doesn’t shy away from singing in an English accent, as she herself has pointed out. Bush is uniquely hard to categorize as an artist, but she’s consistently staked herself out as an English singer.

Even more than most of her albums, Lionheart is cohesively British. This is reflected by such songs as “In Search of Peter Pan” and “Wow,” both of which pile on staples of British culture, and the album’s title. “Lionheart” is a word mostly associated with England, conjuring up images of Richard the Lionheart and British staunchness. Its connotation is of fearlessness and an endless march, of “God Save the Queen” and Trafalgar. Even the cover of Lionheart suggests frigidity: Kate Bush sits in an attic with gold cloth draped around her, perched on top of a wooden chest, with a stuff lion’s face resting on the floor next to her. There’s a standoffishness to it which the anabatic, orientalist cover of The Kick Inside lacks. The cover suggests that this is a more serious album, one that’s placing itself in a lineage of British stalwarts.

The title track “Oh England My Lionheart” engages with this British tradition. It is a classical song in a fair few regards. Unlike most of Bush’s music, the song is played features acoustic instruments exclusively, including Richard Harvey’s recorder and Francis Monkman’s harpsichord. If reading that you thought “huh, this sounds like a Renaissance song,” you would be correct. Bush described the song as being done “madrigally.” It’s not difficult to imagine “Oh England My Lionheart” being used in a classicist production of Twelfth Night. “Lionheart” sounds like a folk song, with its fixed structure of repeated chords, its descending melody, and its lengthy descriptions of scenery. This isn’t the first time Bush has interacted with folk music, of course. Bush often imbues antiquated styles with her own vision of strange things. With “Oh England My Lionheart” she takes the folk ballad and takes it on a tour through England, from the Thames to London Bridge to Kensington Park. Yet for its breadth, “Oh England My Lionheart” is dreary, positively crawling through its three minutes and twelve seconds. Bush is outright crooning in this song, doing little heavy lifting on lyrics like “give me one wish/and I’d be wassailing.” It’s an uncharacteristically mellow performance with an iffy production. Few songs could get over these hurdles, and “Oh England My Lionheart” is put to the test by them.

The production does the song a disservice, as it makes “Oh England My Lionheart” sound more conservative than it actually is. It’s easy to read the song as a nationalist ballad, but “Lionheart” is more nuanced than that. The song narrowly treads a line with its war-inflected imagery, but let’s look at exactly what Bush explores here. She’s living in a postwar England where “the air raid shelters are blooming clover.” “Dropped from my black Spitfire to my funeral barge,” Bush sings as if the country is going to land on her. Pastoral England is growing over wartime England. The country is a romantic lead here, giving solitude to those in it. “Oh England My Lionheart” is a return to Bush songs about spying on an inaccessible love. Bush cries “I don’t want to go” in the outro, desperate for her country to stay with her. Without England, there is no Kate Bush, and she knows it.

The problem with this is that it risks tipping into nationalism. There’s enough mythic weight and ambiguity to “Lionheart” that it avoids being outright jingoistic, but Bush doesn’t seem to realize the extent to which there is ambiguity. In retrospect she dismissed it as her “patriotic number,” but at the time of the album’s release she spoke keenly of English nostalgia. It’s not too hard to imagine right-wing Bush fans taking “Oh England My Lionheart” the wrong way. But to hold misreadings of a text against the text is unfair. English writers inevitably deal with mythic visions of Albion. Now we know what Bush’s particular vision is: tangible and easily grasped, yet still at arm’s length.

Comments

Sleepyscholar 3 months ago

This is a song I come close to actively disliking, and your analysis makes it clearer to me why. There's the problem with the actual music, of course, and on top of that you have the 'nationalist' angle, which I found more unpalatable the older I got.

I think there's an added dimension to the 'pastoral' angle, as well. Kate is not from the country. Yes, a farmhouse, yes a village, but she was born and grew up in Greater London. So she has a particularly powerful case of suburban ambiguity. I think growing up in this halfway house state leads you to valorise both alternatives excessively. So the city becomes this intense, vibrant, sexy fast-moving place, while the country is essentially an externalised womb. The country is a pastoral vision of greens, cricket and lazy summers in fields... for those who don't actually have to work there (the reality of rural life for many is poverty and very high rates of work-related accidents, suicide, etc).

So the pastoral image of England is latched onto by nationalists (from John Major to Nigel Farage), and it's a very appealing image for people like me who were born and grew up in suburbs (ie middle classes). It's less appealing for the urban working class, I think.

When I was the age Kate was when she wrote the song, I too was 'patriotic' (I supported Thatcher's war against Argentina). And I dismiss that, perhaps in the same way that she dismisses this song. Yet I also retain some sense of anti-nationalist nostalgia, which I most recently found activated by the film Arcadia (recommended, by the way: https://www.arcadia.film/).

Your argument that it's unfair to blame a text for misreadings of the text is fair, but I'm afraid it doesn't redeem the song any for my ears!

Link | Reply

Comment deleted 3 months ago

Comment deleted 3 months ago

Comment deleted 3 months ago

Comment deleted 2 months, 4 weeks ago

Comment deleted 2 months, 4 weeks ago

Comment deleted 2 months, 4 weeks ago

Comment deleted 2 months, 4 weeks ago

Comment deleted 2 months, 3 weeks ago

bombasticus 3 months ago

As someone who almost dawdled too long buying the first BFI Derek Jarman box (with its punk pastorales), I really like the somewhat varicose vocabulary here, like a Churchill mug smashed in a duel and pasted back together, good as new if not for the spiderweb of burst unity. Please do not change one comma or, if doing so, make it a separate Director's Cut version. Seriously.

Link | Reply

bombasticus 2 months, 4 weeks ago

Deleted! I am sad to have offended with talk of Jarman pastorales and commas. Will leave you to it then.

Link | Reply

Elizabeth 2 months, 4 weeks ago

Sorry! Must have misclicked while whacking spam. Have restored.

Link | Reply

bombasticus 2 months, 4 weeks ago

:)
or rather / X )
pray god we can cope

Link | Reply

Comment deleted 2 months, 3 weeks ago

Comment deleted 1 month, 3 weeks ago

tupper o the track 1 month, 2 weeks ago

I see it as a celebration of when Europe was washed clean of fascist filth, and England beat her breast, quite rightly, and gave thanks that she had assisted in that great struggle against the enemy of everything that stood in the way of building the country where artists like kate would be able to express themselves

Link | Reply

Comment deleted 1 month, 1 week ago

New Comment

required

required (not published)

optional

Recent Posts

Archive

Tags

Authors

Feeds

RSS / Atom