2 years, 1 month ago
In case you missed it, I interviewed Peter Harness
On to new business, the Hugo Awards will be announced this evening, so let's just call this a thread to talk about those, even if that does mean things won't really pick up much until Sunday.
In any case, a brief note about them, made in advance of any actual outcomes. The Puppies, and particularly Vox Day, have insisted that widespread victories for No Award would constitute a victory for them.
You know what would constitute a victory for the Puppies? What they actually campaigned for, which was their slate. If their slate gets roundly and rejected and defeated, that's called losing.
In fact, this is pretty straightforward. If Puppy nominees win, it's a victory for fascist scum. If No Award wins, it's a victory for SJWs. If non-puppy nominees win, it's a victory for moderates like George R.R. Martin who put value orthodox sci-fi fandom for its own sake and independently of what it actually does.
Two of those outcomes mark a defeat for my position and my view. One doesn't. Just about the only exception is the Dramatic Works categories, where the Puppy slates were mostly not that different from what would normally get nominated, and even there, I'm inclined to view it as a category where there's just less to gain for the Puppies compared to the other two sides.
But either way, the winners are going to be, you know, the ones who win.
Share on Facebook