4 years, 11 months ago
I've realised who Strax reminds me of: the policeman from 'Allo 'Allo
. But not as good. That's a cheap shot, but I do have a serious point to make.
Strax, you see, is essentially a funny foreigner. You know, with his allegedly hilarious misunderstandings and all that stuff. Moffat evidently imagines that Strax's misunderstandings are a rich and continuing source of humour, since he stops the plot of 'Deep Breath' for a few minutes so that he can (once again) run through all the same Strax jokes he's already done several hundred times in other episodes. (This, by the way, is another way in which Strax resembles a character from 'Allo 'Allo
- he is the same joke, repeated endlessly, over and over again, with the laugh demanded - upon recitation of a well-known catchphrase - from an audience supposedly trained via pavlovian technique. If you object to my singling out 'Allo 'Allo
here then, really, I agree with you. How about we use Little Britain
as our example instead?)
Of course, the funny foreigner - with all the imperial contempt and jingoistic chauvinism that is built in to it - is a very old, traditional, endlessly recurring character in British comedy. Shakespeare, for instance, relied upon it heavily, with his nebbishy Welshmen Fluellen and Dr Evans, his amusingly touchy Irishman MacMorris, and his randy preening French vanitycase Dr Caius, etc etc etc. So we can't be too hard on Moffat here. He is, after all, simply doing (yet again) something very old, venerable and respected, despite it being unfunny and based in national chauvinism. Can't really blame him, can you?
As I say, however, Strax isn't as good as the policeman in 'Allo 'Allo
... because the policeman in 'Allo 'Allo (you remember, he used to come in and mispronounce his words - it was terribly amusing) is actually a jab at the English, at the English habit of imagining that, rather than bother to learn foreign languages, all you have to do is speak English at foreigners, but with an attempt at their accent, and in a loud voice, and they'll get it... because English is the only proper language, and people who don't speak it are thus functionally the same as the mentally disabled, and everyone knows that people with mental illness just need to try harder.
I don't mean to attribute attitudes like that to Moffat. But its a shame that he falls back on a comedy trope that is so incredibly dodgy. Though, in fairness, the employment of dodgy foreigner stereotypes (comic or otherwise) is not exactly unknown to pre-Moffat Doctor Who
. And Strax isn't overtly supposed to represent any particular non-British nationality. He's supposed to be an alien. And here we stumble across another complicating factor: the alien in Doctor Who
has always been based on a kind of racial essentialism, a fear of the other, etc etc etc. Strax could arguably be said to be considerably less dodgy than, say, Linx, because he represents a condition of mutual acceptance. He is the other, sure, but the other muddling along amongst us and basically on our side.
But here we run into yet another twist in the story... because this alignment of the other with 'us' is worrying in itself. This recurring team - Vastra, Jenny and Strax - worries me. It represents the reconciliation of the antagonist with 'us'. They don't just live with humans, they live in Victorian London, and this seems to me to be the most blatant possible way of integrating them into a kind of aggressively middle-class, twee, cutesy, ostensibly lovable, yet aggressive and insular and ressentimental Britishness, a Britishness at its most iconically imperialistic and hierarchical. Victoriana is the heavy drapes and elaborate dresses and cravats and top hats of the middle-classes. Victoriana is the coughing, shivering, gin-swilling street poor as an essential background decoration, a set of tropes to locate us. Victoriana is brown derby-wearing police inspectors (probably called Lestrade) who consult toff private detectives because, being working class, they're too thick to do their jobs themselves (the implicit goodness and necessity of the police is never questioned in Victoriana - something that wasn't true amongst common people in actual Victorian London, who often saw the bobbies as incompetents at best, violent spies at worst). Victoriana is empire as backdrop. Queen and country. Big Ben. Smog, gaslight, cobbles, hansom cabs, etc etc etc. This is the milieu that Vastra, Jenny and Strax have assimilated themselves into. Vastra even challenges the bad guys "in the name of the British Empire!" This sort of thing no doubt seems desperately cute to Moffat, and all those people who write those rubbishy Jago & Litefoot audios for Big Finish, but its only our historical amnesia to what the British Empire was that allows this kind of desperate cutesiness to subsist. The subsistence of it, in turn, allows the amnesia. And boy, do we love our symptoms... hence our desire to inflict them on everyone and pull everyone, and everything, into them. The Silurian and the Sontaran, for instance, have joined us in our adorable, pop-Conan-Doyle-inflected national fantasy of a penny dreadful past of wonders and horrors. The horrors are all safely in the past (things we've cured now) and the wonders remain as a kind of nostalgic longing for the lost times when, right or wrong, he had confidence and lush gothic cliches galore on our side. Vastra - the representative of a displaced people who are perpetually denied redress and justice (umm... imperialism? colonialism?) - has isolated herself from her people and integrated herself into imperial Britain. She has ceased to be any kind of rebuke to 'our' world, or 'us'. And 'we' have become the national gestalt that once lived in the United Kingdom of Sherlock. Strax - the representative of a culture of militarism and conquest - has similarly integrated himself. His imperialist attitudes are turned into cute, amusing misprisions which allow him to sink with ease into the warm slippers of imperial Victoriana. The militarism of the Sontarans is no longer a rebuke to 'our' militarism. The Sontaran may not be a threatening other anymore, but he is now no longer, in any sense, a mirror reflecting our own nastier values back at us. He's not a reflection that attacks. He's a stooge who safely reminds us of our foibles by being sillier than us, and then puts on the uniform of a servant and takes his place in the pyramid. The good pyramid. 'Our' pyramid. The pyramid we all fit into somewhere, nicely and neatly. The pyramid that even the comedy tramps fit into. The pyramid in which the chirpy cockney maid voluntarily calls people "ma'am" and serves them their tea, as an empowered life choice. The pyramid of contextless, gutted, sanitised tropes. This is partly why our representations of the Victorian era are so tropetastic... because tropes slot neatly into each other (hence all the Victoriana crossovers, i.e. Holmes vs Jack the Ripper, League of Extraordinary Gentlemen
, etc), arrange themselves into pyramids of perceived cultural weight, and start to resemble a vertiginous but orderly class structure, a sort of naturally-occuring periodic table of the social roles, which is the ideology of Victoriana that we are sold by every bit of culture the tropes come from. This is why 'actually existing steampunk' (which 'Deep Breath' appropriates in predictable fashion, Moffat having been pulling at this particular thread for some time) is so pernicious. Because the iconography of the high era of industrialisation, imperialism and colonialism is reduced to contextless fetishized commodities, sumptuous archaic kit, and safely de-conflicted social classes. And even the identification of the cogwheel and the top hat with villainy nevertheless makes no apology for the joy we're supposed to take in the sheen of the 19th century machine.
Of course, once again, we shouldn't be too hard on Moffat. He's just doing what lots of people do. He's just going along. And he's not doing anything worse than Robert Holmes did in 'Talons of Weng Chiang'. In fact, he's better than that. His obligatory Victorian chinese person looks right, according to the big book of stereotypes... but at least he was played by an actual Chinese person. And at least he wasn't being singled out. At least he was just another brick in the pyramid, another character on the picturesque Quality Street tin that Victorian London has been turned into by our culture industries. That's what we do now. We don't do stories about Victorian London in which Chinese people are The Enemy. The sneer at the foreigner has been displaced elsewhere, translated into code. Now, we do stories in which all races and classes, all costumes and styles, all tropes, are brought together, all present and correct, all slotted into place.
Is that so bad? I honestly don't know. I'm not necessarily arguing that we're looking at a regress. But I'm pretty sure we're not looking at progress. And I'm not talking about the paucity of round things on the wall.
Share on Facebook