My Thoughts on the Missing Episode Finds

(10 comments)

Just wanted to note that my thoughts on the missing episode finds are up on Bleeding Cool. I'll post a rewritten version of the blog posts for Galaxy Four and The Underwater Menace once the episodes become fully available to the public and I can review them.

And while I'm putting a high profile post at the top of my blog while it's probably about to experience heavy traffic, let me say welcome to any incoming Bleeders. If you like what you see here, please do note that the book version of my Hartnell columns, including considerable bonus material not up on the website, is available from Amazon.

Those of you interested in comic books - which I imagine is most anyone coming from Bleeding Cool - may also be interested in my proposed Wonder Woman book, which is currently seeking funding over at Kickstarter.

Comments

talestoenrage 5 years, 11 months ago

As soon as I read the news, I wondered if you'd heard it yet. I have to wonder how much they will change both your opinion of them and the general fan opinion, but there's no way to predict that until we actually see them in full, and I don't know if there's any detail on that just yet.

Link | Reply

Billy Smart 5 years, 11 months ago

I've just got back from the BFI! I sensed that something must be up when I saw that I was sitting behind Gary Russell, Mark Gattis and Ian Levine...

We saw all of Underwater, but only the first ten minutes of Galaxy. Despite its deserved poor reputation, watching Part 3 it always lifts my spirits - its like a school play, filled with silly pulp ideas and fun performances. Part 2 is more of the same, Joseph Furst ranting with delight that he will blow up ze world!, women dressed up in shells and men in headdresses, Polly telling Ben that, "they tried to turn me into a fish!", Jamie more of a highlander than I've seen him realised before, more of that oddly pornographic censored sequence of Colin Jeavons trying to inject Polly. But the one thing that holds it together is that Troughton is sensationally good even this early on - really impish and animated, but still very cunning. And we finally get to see him play the recorder!

Galaxy 4 looks better than it sounded. The design of the dome is pretty neat, and the Stephanie Bidmead character is better realised than I'd anticipated, with a lot of direct address to camera - we'd never have realised that before! Vicky and Stephen are always really good, and cover up for Hartnell... Chumblies are jolly, and I have finally got to see a Rill!

Link | Reply

Philip Sandifer 5 years, 11 months ago

As I said at the time (and I suspect with two episodes available this will become a more prevalent view), Underwater Menace is a fascinating point on the Hartnell-to-Troughton transition, with elements of old "let's explore weird places" Hartnell stuff and elements of the more conventional good vs. evil spectacle of the Troughton era, with Troughton hitting his stride as the Doctor right under everyone's nose. It's not a great story, but it's both important and fascinating, and I hope it gets more attention.

Galaxy Four I have somewhat less patience with, but the clip we got was sublimely well directed, and I'm really interested in seeing more. I think 25 more minutes of Underwater Menace will vindicate me a bit in saying that one's under-appreciated, whereas 25 minutes of Galaxy Four may well prove me totally wrong about that one.

Link | Reply

Jesse Smith 5 years, 11 months ago

"These are not episodes that made anybody’s top ten list of wished for discoveries."

My thoughts exactly! My heart was racing as I opened the link to the BBC website from Google Reader to see exactly which episodes had been found, my mind tumbling with rapid thoughts about which episodes it could be. And then... oh.

But still, I can't wait to see them! I never really expected to see any "new" classic Doctor Who ever again. And like you mentioned in your post, there are a lot of unique things about these episodes that will be fascinating to finally see.

It was really intriguing when The Daleks' Master Plan episode 2 was discovered to compare the live action to the Loose Cannon reconstruction, and the same should be a fascinating exercise with these.

Link | Reply

William Whyte 5 years, 11 months ago

Another review at http://parrot-knight.livejournal.com/818383.html.

Yes, I'd expect Galaxy 4 to look good -- as say, that crane shot from episode 1 is lovely. Looking forward to seeing it.

Link | Reply

AD169 5 years, 11 months ago

Any idea if you will hold off your Troughton volume for this episode? I imagine it could be as long as year before most of us see it.

Link | Reply

Philip Sandifer 5 years, 11 months ago

There's no way I'll be ready with the Troughton volume before a release date is announced. Basically, if it will be a matter of weeks, sure, I'll delay it. If it will be a matter of months, I'll simply note in the book that a revised version of the Underwater Menace essay will be found at some fixed url.

Link | Reply

Seeing_I 5 years, 11 months ago

It's amazing that this material keeps on turning up. Let's hope it's not another 7 years before the next find! Cannot wait to see these.

Link | Reply

SK 5 years, 11 months ago

Aw, no, I got the Lost in Time set because I thought that the likelihood of any more episodes turning up was remote. I mean, yay, and all, and the chumblies are as bizarre as imagined and that scene with Zarkoff is great, but this does mean a revised edition with a concomitant price tag will be the only way to see them (unless you're pirating scum), won't it?

Link | Reply

AD169 5 years, 11 months ago

I think it's far more likely that they will give it a new release, including UM episode 3 and possibly the G4 recon meant for the Time Meddler DVD (which could be updated now). That or they'll stick the episodes on upcoming Hartnell or Troughton releases.

Link | Reply

New Comment

required

required (not published)

optional

Recent Posts

Archive

Tags

Authors

Feeds

RSS / Atom