The Eruditorum Press Doctor Who Poll Results: 100-51

(24 comments)

At last we come to the top 100. Let's dive in.

100: The Gunfighters (19 Points, 2 First Place, 1 Last Place, 2 Downvotes)

The "Jeremy Bentham" point of view went unrepresented until the last set of votes counted. I am disappointed in whoever cast that vote. DISAPPOINTED.

99: The Face of Evil (19 Points, 1 First Place)

98: The Husbands of River Song (19 Points, 1 First Place, 2 Downvotes)

97: The Romans (19 Points, 1 Downvote)

96: The Magician's Apprentice/The Witch's Familiar (19 Points, 4 Downvotes)

95: The Girl Who Died (20 Points, 2 Downvotes)

94: The Lodger (20 Points, 4 Downvotes)

93: Dead Romance (21 Points, 1 First Place, 7 Non-Televised)

Alternatively, this could be the highest-placed Faction Paradox book.

92: The Curse of Fatal Death (21 Points, 4 Non-Televised)

This is another of those ones where the order is really funny.

91: The Impossible Planet/The Satan Pit (21 Points, 1 First Place, 2 Last Place, 3 Downvotes)

90: The Edge of Destruction (22 Points, 1 First Place, 1 Downvote)

89: Planet of the Ood (22 Points, 1 First Place, 1 Downvote)

88: The Green Death (23 Points, 1 First Place, 3 Downvotes)

87: The Invasion (23 Points)

86: The Sun Makers (24 Points, 1 Downvote)

85: The Also People (25 Points, 18 Non-Televised)

84: Terror of the Zygons (25 Points, 1 First Place, 1 Downvote)

83: The Time of Angels/Flesh and Stone (25 Points, 1 Downvote)

82: The Waters of Mars (25 Points, 1 First Place, 2 Last Place, 3 Downvotes)

81: Castrovalva (27 Points, 1 First Place)

80: The God Complex (27 Points, 1 Downvote)

79: The Talons of Weng-Chiang (28 Points, 3 First Place, 4 Last Place, 13 Downvotes)

This was 6th in the most recent Doctor Who Magazine poll. One of the people to put it in first place apologized for doing so. Another person both upvoted and downvoted it. Personally, I'm pretty happy with the fact that it was beaten by

78: The Ambassadors of Death (29 Points, 1 First Place)

One voter went with The Ambassadors... OF DEATH. Another went with the even more emphatic The Ambassadors [Ker-Chow!] OF DEATH

77. Flatline (30 Points)

76. Father's Day (32 Points, 1 Last Place, 1 Downvote)

75: The Aztecs (32 Points, 2 Last Place)

74: Utopia (34 Points, 1 Downvote)

73: The Seeds of Doom (35 Points, 3 First Place, 3 Downvotes)

72: The Pyramids of Mars (35 Points, 2 Downvotes)

The two most overrated Hinchcliffe-era stories finish level on points and pleasantly far down. 

 

71: Face the Raven (35 Points, 1 Last Place, 1 Downvote)

70: Horror of Fang Rock (36 Points)

69: The Evil of the Daleks (37 Points, 2 First Place)

68: The Impossible Astronaut/Day of the Moon (37 Points, 1 First Place, 2 Last Place, 5 Downvotes)

67: The Three Doctors (38 Points)

66: Scherzo (38 Points, 31 Non-Televised)

65: The Night of the Doctor (38 Points, 16 Non-Televised)

Paul McGann's highest "televised" story.

64: The Holy Terror (39 Points, 36 Non-Televised)

63: Mummy on the Orient Express (40 Points)

62: Rose (40 Points, 1 Downvote)

61: Snakedance (41 Points, 1 First Place, 1 Last Place, 1 Downvote)

The person who voted for "Dances with Snakes" flummoxed me until very late in the counting.

60: Timewyrm: Revelation (41 Points, 1 First Place, 30 Non-Televised)

59: The Time Meddler (42 Points, 1 First Place)

58: Revelation of the Daleks (43 Points, 3 First Place)

Colin Baker's highest televised story.

57: Spearhead from Space (43 Points)

56: Love and War (45 Points, 1 First Place, 37 Non-Televised, 1 Downvote)

55: The Greatest Show in the Galaxy (47 Points, 1 First Place, 1 Downvote)

54: Spare Parts (48 Points, 38 Non-Televised)

53: A Christmas Carol (49 Points, 4 First Place, 1 Last Place, 4 Downvotes)

Highest-placed Christmas special.

52: The Girl Who Waited (52 Points, 2 First Place, 1 Downvote)

51: Survival (53 Points, 1 First Place)

 

Just 50 more stories to go, and they'll be up tomorrow. Fun fact: every Doctor has at least one story remaining.

Comments

Dave 7 months, 2 weeks ago

Aw. Disappointed about The Gunfighters. It was a toss up for me between it and Ghost Light for top place and I'm glad I used it to get Gunfighters into the top 100 now.

Link | Reply

Dave 7 months, 2 weeks ago

...Unless Ghost Light narrowly misses out on top spot.

Link | Reply

Przemek 7 months, 2 weeks ago

A surprisingly high score for "Rose". I wonder who voted for it: classic series fans who were extremely happy to see their favourite show return to television or new series fans who remember it fondly as the first Doctor Who story they ever watched?

(Or maybe it's just very good and I simply can't see it. It was my first Doctor Who episode and I remembered it as weird, awkward and not very promising.)

Link | Reply

Max Curtis 7 months, 2 weeks ago

I think its awkwardness is kind of the point. A straightforwardly gritty, down-to-earth reboot wouldn't have felt true to the show's spirit. It's certainly not a perfect episode or one I particularly enjoy watching straight through, but those same faults are why it was basically the perfect way to launch the New Series.

Link | Reply

Kit 7 months, 2 weeks ago

The episode itself is a really awkward piece of television that hurts the eyes with its weird shininess. But as an introduction to Who, as a revival of Who, and as a story pitched at all ages of a family, the script is incredible. No episode of Doctor Who has ever carried so much on its shoulders, and the evidence shows that it achieved its aims magnificently.

(I like very few of Davies' own episodes of the show, and pesonally rank his entire era as one of the lowest in the last 53 years. Rose is one of the most impressive scripts the series has ever had.)

Link | Reply

Andrew 7 months, 2 weeks ago

"Rose" is perfect, in that it fulfils its function/role brilliantly. Of course, it's a bit rubbish, if set against all the rest of Dr. Who and/or television, but that's not the point.

I remember how felt l when I watched it for the first time (March 2006 - the bootlegged version). It was like an old friend was suddenly back. Exactly the same feeling I had with Remembrance of the Daleks back in 1988.

Link | Reply

prandeamus 7 months, 2 weeks ago

I love "Rose", but ....

I remember thinking, "please don't let the bin burp" and then it did. And since I was reading a lot of old grimdark NAs at the time I wasn't happy at the tonal dissonance. And the plastic-faced Mickey.

I used to complain about "anti-plastic". Would it have been better if the Doctor had called it "zectronite"? I found it annoying at the time, but I've grown up since and become more childlike.

Oh the good bits : the world turning speech. The London Eye halo framing Ecclestone's head. The TARDIS reveal.

Fantastic!

Link | Reply

The Not Quite Handsome Doctor 7 months, 2 weeks ago

Another way to look at it: If you consider just the first outings for each Doctor, it looks like Rose is in 5th place, below Spearhead from Space, and ahead of Castrovalva. That seems spot on to me.

Link | Reply

Dan 7 months, 2 weeks ago

It was an electric moment when it came out, and this context affected the way I viewed the whole of the first series. (Also having an overall arc was new, or the way it was done at least was new.) Now it doesn't look the same. It took me a very long time to realise that the new series could be variable in quality just like the old one. Just not so much.

Link | Reply

Przemek 7 months, 2 weeks ago

I guess you are all right about "Rose" - it's all a matter of perspective. Most of what I can remember from watching it is calling the friend who recommended Doctor Who to me and asking: "Um... is the whole show about... fighting plastic mannequins?".

Link | Reply

David Anderson 7 months, 2 weeks ago

Have I missed The Mutants? Also Earthworld?

Link | Reply

Phil Sandifer 7 months, 2 weeks ago

You only sort of missed the Mutants - it was 277th, but apparently I accidentally skipped from 278th to 276th when writing that section up. Two points, one downvote, putting it between The War Machines and Time Heist.

Earthworld did not get any votes.

Link | Reply

David Anderson 7 months, 2 weeks ago

I thought I had (chiefly for Anji's emails).

Link | Reply

David Anderson 7 months, 2 weeks ago

(I thought I had used a non-televised vote for Earthworld that is.)
The other classic story that doesn't seem to have appeared in the poll yet, which I would have thought would have by now, is The Faceless Ones.

Link | Reply

Phil Sandifer 7 months, 2 weeks ago

Doesn't look like you did, no.

Faceless Ones is a mistake. I'll go do the necessary fixing now. /sigh

Link | Reply

Phil Sandifer 7 months, 2 weeks ago

Ah, good, fixing for The Faceless Ones was relatively easy, as I had a "oh shit I don't want to renumber all of this" fake entry in the 119-way (now 118-way) tie that I could remove, meaning I only had to renumber about 25 things.

(What the other cheat entries are is a secret I'll take to my grave, of course.)

Link | Reply

Anthony D Herrera 7 months, 2 weeks ago

Holy Mother Of God I forgot about Ambassadors Of Death. I even looked at my list and saw no Pertwee and was all "There's no law says there has to be." WHY AREN'T THERE MORE LAWS!

Link | Reply

The Not Quite Handsome Doctor 7 months, 2 weeks ago

Huh, does this mean Kinda significantly beat out Snakedance? That's a bit odd, no?

I almost wish I had also thought of simultaneously upvoting and downvoting Talons, but then again I already had enough hard, late cuts to make for my Top 20 (including Snakedance), so I'd probably have squeezed Fang Rock in for my second Leela pick anyway.

Link | Reply

CC0 7 months, 2 weeks ago

At least The Night of the Doctor got into the top 100.
Yes, I love it and I'll defend it TO DEATH!!

Link | Reply

Tim B. 7 months, 2 weeks ago

It is prima facie evidence of us living in a broken world that The Ambassadors [Ker-Chow!] OF DEATH. is not the canonical title.

Link | Reply

The Not Quite Handsome Doctor 7 months, 2 weeks ago

It's the televised title! Ergo, we must accept that it IS canonical, and everyone has just been referring to it incorrectly until now.

Link | Reply

Max Wilkie 7 months, 2 weeks ago

Well, I'm also quite chuffed Ambassadors beat Talons. This is, bar none, the most interesting fan poll of Who stories I've ever seen. Which is an excellent thing for a fan poll to be.

Link | Reply

crossaffliction 7 months, 2 weeks ago

Find it funny that, as I'm the guy who defended Colin Baker in general and "The Twin Dilemma" in specific, the highest rated (televised?) Colin Baker story is one I don't remember voting for.

Link | Reply

Brian Olsen 7 months, 2 weeks ago

I put The Gunfighters in last place - it was me! I confess! And I feel no shame at all! I don't care a bit for Bentham's opinion, it's just that song...god, that song... I'd listen to "Doctor in Distress" on repeat for a week rather than listen to "The Ballad of the Last Chance Saloon" one more time.

Link | Reply

New Comment

required

required (not published)

optional

Recent Posts

Archive

Tags

Authors

Feeds

RSS / Atom